Computers & Chemical Engineering, Vol.48, 154-164, 2013
Another confirmation that counter-current logarithmic mean is upper bound and a note on approximations
The paper presents modifications on published demonstration that the counter-current logarithmic-mean-temperature-difference (Delta T-LM) is upper bound compared with the co-current Delta T-LM. In the published demonstration, an approach was proposed but it suffered from wrong assumption. In this paper, corrections to the wrong assumption and a property of a curve derived from the Delta T-LM curve have been used to propose another demonstration that counter-current Delta T-LM is upper bound. Optimization problems have been formulated to verify the proposed developments and demonstrate the results obtained. A class of Delta T-LM approximations including two accurate approximations proposed by the author are discussed. The selected approximations are designated as Underwood's class. This class generates accurate results over the problem temperature-difference-ratio range and has the advantage of direct use of the heat exchanger (HEX) terminal temperature differences. Crown Copyright (c) 2012 Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords:Co-current HEX;Counter-current HEX;Heat exchanger (HEX);Heat exchanger network (HEN);HEN analysis;HEN synthesis;HEN optimization;Logarithmic-mean-temperature-difference (LMTD) method;Logarithmic-mean-temperature-difference (Delta T-LM);Minimum rule (MR);Process integration;Minimum temperature difference approach (Delta T-min)