The systems 2-methylnaphthalene+2-chloronaphthalene and 2-methylnaphthalene+2-bromonaphthalene belong to the exceptional group of binary systems where the formation of mixed crystals goes together with a solid-liquid phase diagram with a maximum. For these systems a thermodynamic analysis is presented which is based on new phase diagram and thermochemical data. The excess Gibbs energies, excess enthalpies, and excess entropies of the mixed crystalline state all are negative. These properties correspond to a net attraction between methyl and substituted halogen. Additional evidence of such an attraction is given by the outcome of a statistical search on intermolecular contacts, in the crystalline state of pure substances, among methyl+halogen, halogen+halogen, and methyl+methyl.