High-valent iron species are known to act as powerful oxidants in both natural and synthetic systems. While biological enzymes have evolved to prevent self-oxidation by these highly reactive species, development of organic ligand frameworks that are capable of supporting a high-valent iron center remains a challenge in synthetic chemistry. We describe here the reactivity of an Fe(II) complex that is supported by a tripodal sulfonamide ligand with both dioxygen and an oxygen-atom transfer reagent, 4-methylmorpholine-N-oxide (NMO). An Fe(III)-hydroxide complex is obtained from reaction with dioxygen, while NMO gives an Fe(III)-alkoxide product resulting from activation of a C-H bond of the ligand. Inclusion of Ca2+ ions in the reaction with NMO prevented this ligand activation and resulted in isolation of an Fe(III)-hydroxide complex in which the Ca2+ ion is coordinated to the tripodal sulfonamide ligand and the hydroxo ligand. Modification of the ligand allowed the Fe(III)-hydroxide complex to be isolated from NMO in the absence of Ca2+ ions, and a C-H bond of an external substrate could be activated during the reaction. This study highlights the importance of robust ligand design in the development of synthetic catalysts that utilize a high-valent iron center.