Triarylmethyl (trityl, TAM) based spin labels represent a promising alternative to nitroxides for EPR distance measurements in biomolecules. Herewith, we report synthesis and comparative study of series of model DNA duplexes, 5'-spin-labeled with TAMs and nitroxides. We have found that the accuracy (width) of distance distributions obtained by double electron electron resonance (DEER/PELDOR) strongly depends on the type of radical. Replacement of both nitroxides by TAMs in the same spin-labeled duplex allows narrowing of the distance distributions by a factor of 3. Replacement of one nitroxide by TAM (orthogonal labeling) leads to a less pronounced narrowing but at the same time gains sensitivity in DEER experiment due to efficient pumping on the narrow EPR line of TAM. Distance distributions in nitroxide/nitroxide pairs are influenced by the structure of the linker: the use of a short amine-based linker improves the accuracy by a factor of 2. At the same time, a negligible dependence on the linker length is found for the distribution width in TAM/TAM pairs. Molecular dynamics calculations indicate greater conformational disorder of nitroxide labels compared to TAM ones, thus rationalizing the experimentally observed trends. Thereby, we conclude that double spin-labeling using TAMs allows obtaining narrower spin-spin distance distributions and potentially more precise distances between labeling sites compared to traditional nitroxides.