Native silk fibers exhibit strength and toughness that rival those of the best synthetic fibers. Despite significant research, further insight is still needed to understand the mechanisms by which silkworms are capable of spinning such tough fibers. Here we propose that pi-pi and pi-OH group interactions of tyrosine side chains provide templating effects, such that the crystal-forming domains are in registration, thereby fostering the self-assembly of the spinning dope. Intrinsic fluorescence measurements, in conjunction with circular dichroism, showed that during self-assembly of regenerated silk solutions, the tyrosine residues were localized in a more hydrophobic local environment, suggesting preferential assembly. In situ Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy indicated that cross-linking of the tyrosine residues resulted in the development of extended beta-sheet structure. Additionally, control of cross-link density directly influenced the degree of crystallinity upon drying. Molecular dynamics simulations were performed on silk mimetic peptides in order to more thoroughly understand the role of tyrosines. The results indicated that tyrosine residues tended to transiently colocate in solution due to pi-pi interactions and hydrogen bonds with adjacent residues and with the peptide backbone. These more stable tyrosine interactions resulted in reduced lateral chain fluctuations and increased incidence of coordinated intrachain association, while introduction of a dityrosine bond directly promoted the formation of beta-sheet structures. In total, the experimental and modeling data support a critical role for tyrosine-tyrosine interactions as a key early feature in the self-assembly of regenerated silk protein chains and therefore are important in the robust and unusual mechanical properties ultimately achieved in the process.