The hierarchical assembly of colored cationic molecules with receptor-modified counteranions can be used to control optical properties in materials. However, our knowledge of when the optical properties emerge in the hierarchical organization and the variety of cationanion salts that are available to create these materials is limited. In this work, we extend the salts from small halides to large inorganic anions and determine how the structure coevolves with the emission properties using solution assemblies. We study the chromogenic trioxatriangulenium (TOTA(+)) cation and its coassembly with cyanostar (CS) macrocycles selected to modify tetrafluoroborate (BF4-) counteranions through formation of 2:1 sandwich complexes. In the solid state, the TOTA(+) cation stacks in an alternating manner with the sandwich complexes producing new red-shifted emission and absorption bands. Critical to assigning the structural origin of the new optical features across the four levels of organization (1 degrees (R) 4 degrees) is the selection of specific solvents to produce and characterize different assemblies present in the hierarchical structure. A key species is the electrostatically stabilized ion pair between the TOTA(+) cation and sandwich complex. The red-shifted features only emerge when the ion pairs oligomerize together into larger (TOTA[CS2BF4])(n) assemblies. New electronic states emerge as a result of multiple copies of the TOTA(+) making pi-contact with cyanostar-anion complexes. Our findings and the ease with which the materials can be prepared as crystals and films by mixing the salt with a receptor provide a strong platform for the de novo design of new optical materials.