The phase behavior and thermodynamic properties of mixtures of pyrene and model vinyl polymers with and without aromatic side groups are investigated using differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) measurements. The melting temperature and associated heat of melting of the pyrene crystals in the mixtures are utilized to extract the effective interaction parameters chi and the composition of polymer-rich phases, respectively. They of pyrene mixed with polymers with aromatic side groups investigated in this study, polystyrene, poly(2-vinylpyridine), and poly(3-vinylanisole), is less than 0.5 at the melting point of the pyrene crystals, suggesting that pyrene and the polymers with aromatic sides groups are enthalpically compatible, likely due to aromatic pi-pi interactions. In contrast, the chi of pyrene mixed with poly(1,4-isoprene) or poly(ethylene-alt-propylene) is larger than 0.5. The DSC measurements also enable characterization of the composition of polymer-rich phases. Interestingly, the polymers with aromatic side groups are found to have more pronounced miscibility with pyrene at symmetric compositions.