Controlling the sequence of repeat units in a synthetic polymer has been a long-standing topic of interest in chemistry. As methods to regulate sequence become more sophisticated, it is critical to consider how controlling the arrangement of repeat units along the polymer backbone impacts properties. In this work, thiophene-selenophene copolymers (statistical and periodic) were compared to elucidate the impact of periodicity on electronic properties and structural organization in conjugated macromolecules. Polymers were synthesized using catalyst-transfer polycondensation (CTP) enabling control over molecular weight and dispersity. The study revealed that optical bandgaps and redox potentials of periodic and statistical copolymers varied with composition in a predictable manner, regardless of monomer ordering along the chain. While the bandgaps of the two types of copolymers were indistinguishable, X-ray scattering revealed differences in solid-state packing. Both types of copolymers exhibited well-defined morphologies, but larger pi-stacking distances and more orientational disorder were evident in the statistical systems. This indicates periodicity is an attribute that should be considered when synthesizing semiconducting materials.