Silicon monoxide is a promising alternative anode material due to its much higher capacity than graphite, and improved cyclability over other Si anodes. An in-depth analysis of the lithium silicide (LixSi) phases that form during lithiation/delithiation of SiO is presented here and the results are compared with pure-Si anodes. A series of anode materials is first prepared by heating amorphous silicon monoxide (a-SiO) at different temperatures, X-ray diffraction and Si-29 NMR analysis revealing that they comprise small Si domains that are surrounded by amorphous SiO2, the domain size and crystallinity growing with heat treatment. In and ex situ Li-7 and Si-29 solid-state NMR combined with detailed electrochemical analysis reveals that a characteristic metallic LixSi phase is formed on lithiating a-SiO with a relatively high Li concentration of x = 3.4-3.5, which is formed/decomposed through a continuous structural evolution involving amorphous phases differing in their degree of Si-Si connectivity. This structural evolution differs from that of pure-Si electrodes where the end member, crystalline Li15Si4, is formed/decomposed through a two-phase reaction. The reaction pathway of SiO depends, however, on the size of the ordered Si domains within the pristine material. When crystalline domains of >3 nm within a SiO2 matrix are present, a phase resembling Li15Si4 forms, albeit at a higher overpotential. The continuous formation/decomposition of amorphous LixSi phases without the hysteresis and phase change associated with the formation of c-Li15Si4, along with a partially electrochemically active SiO2/lithium silicate buffer layer, are paramount for the good cyclability of a-SiO.