Nerve growth factor (NGF) is an endogenously produced polypeptide that promotes the differentiation, survival, and repair of neurons in the central and peripheral nervous systems. While trophic proteins hold promise for the treatment of neuronal injury and disease, use of NGF is limited by its large molecular weight, lack of permeability through the blood-brain barrier, and peripheral side effects. Previously, we found that an extract of the Momordica cochinchinensis seed stimulated PC-12 neurite outgrowth. Bioactivity-guided fractioning of the seed extract suggested that the NGF mimetic agent was one of few defined proteins from this plant: one group being the defense Knottins and the other group of the lowest mass is the potent trypsin inhibitor MCoTI-II. Here, the NGF mimetic potential of this latter protein was investigated using two concurrent but different approaches. A biological study used recombinant purified MCoTI-II, which when tested in rat PC-12 cells grown on collagen, failed to initiate outgrowth relative to the positive control 7S NGF. In a separate computational study, the possibility was investigated such that MCoTI-II could exert an effect through binding to the serine protease gamma-NGF subunit of the 7S NGF complex, analogous to its binding to its native receptor trypsin. Molecular dynamics simulations showed that MCoTI-II can bind stably to gamma-NGF for >350 ns. Modeling indicated that this interaction could sterically inhibit 7S NGF complex formation, potentially altering the equilibrium between inactive complexed and free active NFG protein. In conclusion, the biological study now excludes the MCoTI-II protein as the NGF mimetic factor in the Momordica extract, an important and required step to identify the active component in this seed. On the other hand, the theoretical study has revealed a novel observation that may be of use in the development of strategies to affect NGF activity.