Photobases are molecules that convert light to proton transfer drive and therefore have potential applications in many areas of chemistry. Previously, we studied the photobasicity of quinolines and explored their applications. While it is possible to tether a photobase near a target proton donor, for the sake of versatility it is desirable to explore their capability to deprotonate molecules dispersed in a solution. Previous evidence suggested that in this scenario at least two proton donors were necessary for successful excited state proton transfer: one to donate a proton and the second to stabilize the photogenerated donor anion. Here we report kinetic evidence from transient absorption (TA) and time-correlated single photon counting (TCSPC) in support of this hypothesis. We used 5-methoxyquinoline as the photobase and 2,2,2-trifluoroethanol (TFE), a low pK(a) alcohol, as the proton donor. A constant concentration of the photobase was used for a range of proton-donor dilutions spanning several orders of magnitude in an aprotic background solvent. Absorption spectra confirm that over most of the studied range the majority of the photobase population is hydrogen bonded to at least one donor. Short-pulse TA was used to measure the faster (2-500 ps) dynamics, while TSCPC was used to measure the slower (>500 ps) dynamics. The measured proton transfer time constants varied as a function of donor concentration over a wide range. A log-log plot of the proton transfer rate constant as a function of proton-donor concentration shows two regimes: nondiffusive at high donor concentrations where multiple proton donors are near the photobase and diffusive at low donor concentrations where proton donors are more dilute. The nondiffusive regime has a slope of approximately one, suggesting that the proton transfer process is dependent on one donor molecule in addition to the donor molecule already hydrogen bonded with the photobase. The diffusive regime reasonably follows diffusion kinetics. We propose a model for how the second proton-donor molecule may interact with the photogenerated alkoxide to stabilize it. This work highlights the importance of inducing irreversible changes, in this case solvation of the alkoxide, after proton transfer. Understanding of such details is likely to be important in applications of photobases.