Platinum(IV) complexes containing carboxylate and carbamate ligands at the axial position have been reported previously. A better understanding of the similarity and difference between the two types of ligands will provide us with new insights and more choices to design novel Pt(IV) complexes. In this study, we systematically investigated and compared the properties of Pt(IV) complexes bearing the two types of ligands. Ten pairs of unsymmetric Pt(IV) complexes bearing axial carbamate or carboxylate ligands were synthesized and characterized. The stability of these Pt(IV) complexes in a PBS buffer with or without a reducing agent was investigated, and most of these complexes exhibited good stability. Besides, most Pt(IV) prodrugs with carbamate axial ligands were reduced faster than the corresponding ones with carboxylate ligands. Furthermore, the aqueous solubilities and lipophilicities of these Pt(IV) complexes were tested. All the carbamate complexes showed better aqueous solubility and decreased lipophilicity as compared to those of the corresponding carboxylate complexes, due to the increased polarity of carbamate ligands. Biological properties of these complexes were also evaluated. Many carbamate complexes showed cytotoxicity similar to that of the carboxylate complexes, which may derive from the lower cellular accumulation but faster reduction of the former. Our research highlights the differences between the Pt(IV) prodrugs containing carbamate and carboxylate axial ligands and may contribute to the future rational design of Pt-based anticancer prodrugs.