In this paper, two different types of solar thermal collector are compared on an exergy basis in the context of a sugarcane cogeneration power plant in Colombia. The analysis is conducted considering the use of solar energy as a way to preheat the boiler feedwater and thereby reduce the fuel consumption and exergy destruction of the power plant. The energy and exergy analyses of the power plant are conducted under real and steady-state conditions. A parabolic trough collector and a linear Fresnel collector are compared, and their exergy performances are assessed. The comparison is conducted considering both solar fields are sized to preheat the boiler feedwater from 95 degrees C to 150 degrees C. The inclusion of the solar thermal collectors reduces the fuel consumption by 1.1% during a typical meteorological year, equivalent to 6400 tons of bagasse per year. Furthermore, the PTC generated 35% more heat per m2 of aperture area during the year than LFC. A better solar exergy harvesting was achieved for the PTC. However, the results do not show significant differences in terms of exergy destruction and fuel savings between the PTC and the LFC. (C) 2020 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.