In vibration welding of thermoplastics, frictional heat generated by vibrating two parts under pressure, along their common interface, is used to effect welds. In the normal, well-understood mode, the vibratory motion is along the weld seam, which is at right angles to the thickness direction for straight boundaries. But in many applications, such as in the welding of closed seams of box-like parts, this vibratory motion occurs in the part-thickness direction, so that a portion of the molten layer along the seam is exposed to the ambient air during each vibratory cycle. The resulting reduction in temperature can affect weld quality. The process phenomenology and the weld strengths of such cross-thickness vibration-welded butt joints are investigated for four neat resins. Weld amplitudes and weld pressures are shown to affect the strengths of 120-Hz welds differently. It is shown that strengths on the order of the strengths of the neat resins can be achieved in 250-Hz butt welds.