The in situ decomposition of ammonium thiometallates during the hydrodesulfurization (HDS) of dibenzothiophene (DBT), to obtain molybdenum disulfide and tungsten disulfide catalysts, was investigated. It was found that very efficient catalysts for the HDS of DBT were obtained by in situ decomposition. Mechanical uniaxial pressing of the precursors (ammonium thiometallates) affected both textural and catalytic properties of the catalysts. Surface areas of molybdenum and tungsten disulfides increased as a function of uniaxial pressing, while catalytic activities went through a maximum. For MoS2, the hydrogenation selectivity was much higher for in situ catalysts than for ex situ ones. For WS2 catalysts, the hydrogenation selectivity was less sensitive to the condition of decomposition (ex situ/in situ). The surface S/M (M = Mo, W) atomic ratio from the Auger signal decreased as a function of uniaxial pressing, while the CIM ratio remained almost constant at 1.6. The best catalyst showed an experimental S/Mo ratio that is slightly higher than the stoichiometric value. The effect of ill situ decomposition and mechanical deformation of thiometallate precursors is discussed.