The thermal and crystal morphological properties of amorphous and melt crystallized poly(oxy-1,4-phenyleneoxy-1,4-phenylenecarbonyl-1,4-phenylene) (PEEK) were investigated. Two different molecular weights were studied by Temperature Modulated DSC (TMDSC) over a broad range of annealing times and temperatures. The lower molecular weight PEEK under all crystallization conditions was found to exhibit secondary crystal melting in the low endotherm region, followed by melting of primary crystals superimposed with a large recrystallization contribution. Primary crystal melting broadly overlapped with melting of the recrystallized species and contributed to the broad highest endotherm. Recrystallization contributions and the interpretation of TMDSC were partially confirmed by independent rapid heating rate melting point determinations and variable heating rate DSC. The higher molecular weight PEEK showed many similarities but generally had smaller levels of reorganization above the annealing temperature under most higher temperature crystallization conditions. TMDSC provides excellent resolution of recrystallization and related events compared to standard DSC. The broad and substantial exothermic recrystallization in amorphous samples was also examined, showing that recrystallization continues through the final melting region.