Seven proton conducting membranes based on different commercial fluoropolymer films were prepared by radiation grafting with styrene followed by sulfonation. These membranes were studied as candidates for fuel cell electrolyte membranes and compared to Nafion(R) 105 and 117 with respect to conductivity, oxygen and hydrogen permeability, kinetics of the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) and performance in a fuel cell. The dependence of the conductivity of the membranes on the relative humidity (RH) and temperature was also determined. The conductivity was observed to depend on the membrane thickness and the water uptake. The dependence of the conductivity on the temperature and the RH was the same for all of the experimental membranes. Reactant gas permeabilities appeared to depend only slightly on the matrix material and no major differences in the Tafel slopes and exchange current densities of the ORR were observed. Membranes with high water uptakes appeared to be less durable in the fuel cell than membranes with low water uptakes. Thus to prepare a membrane that is durable under the fuel cell conditions, the water uptake must remain low even at the expense of the conductivity.