Binary Cu/ZnO and Cu/Al2O3 as well as ternary Cu/ZnO/Al2O3 catalysts were investigated with respect to their catalytic activity and stability in methanol synthesis. In a rapid aging test, activity measurements were carried out in combination with the determination of the specific Cu surface area. A close correlation between the loss of catalytic activity and the decrease in specific Cu surface area was found due to sintering of the Cu particles. Differences in the deactivation behavior and the area-activity relationship of each catalyst system imply that the catalysts should be grouped in different classes.