Wetting behavior was studied on surfaces with a single, circular heterogeneous island. Lyophobic islands were created on lyophilic Si wafers using polystyrene. Alternately, lyophobic perfluoroalkoxy fluoropolymer film was etched to make lyophilic domains. Contact angles and hysteresis were measured with water and hexadecane. Small sessile drops were deposited on the center of an island and liquid was sequentially added, eventually forcing the contact line to advance beyond the island perimeter onto the surrounding area. Even though the underlying contact area contained a mixture of lyophilic and lyophobic domains, the contact angles, both advancing and receding, were equal to the angles exhibited by the homogeneous periphery. Or in other words, if the heterogeneity was completely contained with the contact area and did not intersect the contact line, then no area averaging of the contact angles occurred. These findings suggest that interactions at the contact line, not the contact area, control wetting of heterogeneous surfaces.