The effects of two nearly isoenergetic C-H stretching motions on the gas-phase reaction of atomic chlorine with methane are examined. First, a 1:4:9 mixture of Cl-2, CH4, and He is coexpanded into a vacuum chamber. Then, either the antisymmetric stretch (nu(3) = 3019 cm(-1)) of CH4 is prepared by direct infrared absorption or the infrared-inactive symmetric stretch (nu(1) = 2917 cm(-1)) of CH4 is prepared by stimulated Raman pumping. Photolysis of Cl-2 at 355 nm generates fast Cl atoms that initiate the reaction with a collision energy of 1290+/-175 cm(-1) (0.16+/-0.02 eV). Finally, the nascent HCol or CH3 products are detected state-specifically via resonance enhanced multiphoton ionization and separated by mass in a time-of-flight spectrometer. We find that the rovibrational distributions and state-selected differential cross sections of the HCl and CH3 products from the two vibrationally excited reactions are nearly indistinguishable. Although Yoon et al. [J. Chem. Phys. 119, 9568 (2003)] report that the reactivities of these two different types of vibrational excitation are quite different, the present results indicate that the reactions of symmetric-stretch excited or antisymmetric-stretch excited methane with atomic chlorine follow closely related product pathways. Approximately 37% of the reaction products are formed in HCl(v = 1,J) states with little rotational excitation. At low J states these products are sharply forward scattered, but become almost equally forward and backward scattered at higher J states. The remaining reaction products are formed in HCl(v = 0,J) and have more rotational excitation. The HCl(v = 0,J) products are predominantly back and side scattered. Measurements of the CH3 products indicate production of a non-negligible amount of umbrella bend excited methyl radicals primarily in coincidence with the HCl(v = 0,J) products. The data are consistent with a model in which the impact parameter governs the scattering dynamics. (C) 2004 American Institute of Physics.