Total syntheses of alkaloid 251F (1), a natural product detected from the skin extracts of the dendrobatid frog species Minyobates bombetes, and its racemic 3-desmethyl derivative (2) are reported. A Diels-Alder reaction initiated both syntheses and established four consecutive stereogenic centers. Important to the synthesis of 2 was a first-generation ozonolysis/olefination/aldol strategy to convert a [2.2.1] bicyclic acid to the [3.3.0]bicyclooctane diquinane 4b. Further elaboration to an appropriate keto azide allowed for a key intramolecular Schmidt reaction to deliver the tricyclic core of the target molecule. In a second-generation approach, a tandem ring-opening/ring-closing metathesis reaction effected an overall [2.2.1] --> [3.3.0] skeletal rearrangement to deliver diquinane 4a. In similar fashion, 4a was manipulated to an appropriate keto azide, and an intramolecular Schmidt reaction generated the core cyclic architecture of 251F.