It is shown how stable nonaqueous suspensions of fully exfoliated smectite clays such as Laponite and montmorillonite can be obtained. Suspensions in toluene and in a branched aliphatic solvent (polydecene) were characterized using elemental analysis, rheometry, and small-angle X-ray scattering. For Laponite, stable suspensions were obtained by adsorbing a dichain poly(isobutylene) based stabilizer to the particles. This approach did not result in full exfoliation for montmorillonite particles, possibly because the stabilizer was able to connect individual clay sheets at the edges during the treatment process. Instead, a quaternary ammonium surfactant, dimethyl dioctadecylammonium bromide (DODAB), was first adsorbed to the clay. Subsequently, adsorption of the poly(isobutylene) based stabilizer to this pretreated clay resulted in fully exfoliated suspensions of montmorillonite. Suspensions of clay particles treated only with DODAB have been studied by several authors before and are included in this study for comparison. A detailed discussion of the suspension behavior of the different clay samples is given. The suspension routes presented here may enable further studies of the structure and flow behavior of suspensions of thin, flexible clay platelets as a function of aspect ratio.