A comparative study of the influence of Co (or Ni) promoter loadings and the effect of different sulfurizing agents and sulfurizing temperatures on the structure, morphology and catalytic performance of Mo- or W-based hydrodesulfurization (HDS) catalysts was carried out. Catalyst performance using a tubular fixed-bed reactor and the HDS of thiophene as a model reaction was evaluated. The oxidic and sulfurized states of the HDS catalysts were characterized by laser Raman spectroscopy, thermogravimetric analysis (TGA), differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and high resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM). It has been found that the urea-matrix combustion (UMxC) synthesis is a simple tool for preparing supported catalysts in a short period of thermal treatment. Several consecutive stages such as urea melting, metal precursor dissolution and chemical reactions take place before and upon combustion process. The C4H4S/H-2-activated Co- (or Ni-) promoted MoS2 (or WS2) catalysts present a strong synergistic effect (SE) when the Co (or Ni)/Mo (or W) molar ratio is near to 0.5, whereas the C-4/C-4 (=) molar ratios display a weak antagonistic effect. Alumina-supported Ni-W catalyst showed an optimal SE 2.5 times higher than those for Co (or Ni)-promoted Mo HDS catalysts. The kinetic parameters for thiophene-HDS reaction were also determined, suggesting that the C-S bond cleavage reaction for alumina-supported Co(Ni)-Mo HDS catalysts and H-2 activation reaction for Ni-promoted WS(2)catalysts play an important role in the rate-limiting step.