Color Research and Application, Vol.23, No.5, 302-313, 1998
Visual determination of hue suprathreshold color-difference tolerances
This research extends the previous RIT-DuPont research on suprathreshold color-difference tolerances in which CIELAB was sampled in a balanced factorial design to quantify global lack of visual uniformity. The current experiments sampled hue, specifically;, Three complete hue circles at two lightnesses (L* = 40 and 60) and two chroma levels (C-ab*=20 and 40) pills thr-ee of the Jive CIE recommended colors (red, green, blue) were scaled visually, for hire discrimination, resulting in 39 color centers. Forty-five observers participated in a forced-choice perceptibility experiment, where rite total color difference of 393 sample pairs were compared with ct near-neutral anchor-pair stimulus of 1.03 Delta E-ab*. A supplemental experiment was performed by 30 additional observers in order to validate four of the 39 colar centers. A fetal of 34,626 visual observations were made under the recently established CIE recommended reference conditions defined for the CIE94 color-difference equation. The statistical method logit analysis with three-dimensional normit function was used to determine the hue discrimination for each color center A three-dimensional analysis was required due to precision limitations of a digital printer used to practice the majority of colored samples. There was unwanted variance in lightness and chroma in addition to the required variance in hue, This statistical technique enabled estimates of only hue discrimination. The three-dimensional analysis was validated in the supplemental experiment, where automotive coatings produced with a minimum of unwanted variance yielded the same visual tolerances when analyzed using one-dimensional probit analysis. The results indicated that the hue discrimination suprathresholds of the pooled observers varied with CIELAB here angle position. The suprathreshold also increased with the chroma position of a given color center; consistent with previous visual results. The results were compared with current difference formulas: CMC, BFD, and CIE94. All three for-mulas had statistically equivalent performance when used to predict the visual data. Given the lack of a hue-angle dependent function embedded in CIE94, it is clear from these results that neither CMC nor BFD adequately predict the visual dam. Thus, these and other hue-suprathreshold data can be used to develop a new color-difference formula with superior performance to current equations.