Synthetic extracellular matrix hydrogels can be used for three-dimensional cell culture, wound repair, and tissue engineering. Using the bifunctional electrophile poly(ethylene glycol) diacrylate (PEGDA), thiol-modified glycosaminoglycans and polypeptides can be cross-linked into biocompatible materials in the presence of cells or tissues. However, the rate of in situ cross-linking with PEGDA under physiological conditions may occur too slowly for clinical applications requiring a fast-curing preparation. To explore a wider range of cross-linking time courses, five homo-bifunctional PEG derivatives were synthesized and examined as cross-linking agents for thiol-modified derivatives of hyaluronan (HA). Thiol reaction rate constants were measured over a pH range of 7.4 to 8.6. The order of reactivity for the functional groups used was determined to be maleimide > iodoacetate > bromoacetate > iodoacetamide > acrylate >> bromoacetamide, with rates increasing exponentially with increasing pH. The range of gelation times at physiological pH varied from less than 1 min to over 2 h. Addition of the cross-linkers to cell culture medium showed minimal cytotoxicity toward primary human dermal fibroblasts at concentrations anticipated during in situ cross-linking. Moreover, hydrogels prepared from thiol-modified gelatin and thiol-modified HA were biocompatible and supported attachment and proliferation of fibroblasts and hepatocytes.