We have found discrepancies between the predictions of two double-reptation models and the corresponding linear viscoelasticity measurements for commercial, polydisperse polystyrene samples with weight-average molecular weights ranging from 140 to 300kg/mol. The accuracy of the experimental data has been confirmed by conducting viscoelasticity measurements in different laboratories using different types of rheometers and by verifying that small distortions in chromatographic measurements cannot account for the discrepancies seen in the viscoelastic response. In addition, we show that the discrepancies between predictions and measurements are systematic, suggesting that gaps in the theory are responsible for the mismatch. Is it concluded that commercial polystyrene resins may pose additional challenges for rheological modeling because of their relatively high polydispersity and low degree of entanglement. The experimental data given here can be used to validate future modeling efforts.