Biliprotein lyases attach linear-tetrapyrrolic bilins covalently to apoproteins, which is a prerequisite for the assembly of phycobiliproteins into phycobilisomes, the light-harvesting complexes of cyanobacteria. On the basis of the addition of thiol and imidazole to phycocyanobilin, we propose a generalized lyase reaction mechanism. The adducts contain isomerized phycocyanobilin that can be transferred by the lyase to apoproteins by either back-isomerization, generating phycocyanobilin-containing proteins, or direct transfer, generating phycoviolobilin-containing proteins.