The recent demonstration that the carbene cluster (Fe4S4((Pr2NHCMe2)-N-i)(4)] (9) is an accurate structural and electronic analogue of the fully reduced cluster of the iron protein of Azotobacter vinelandii nitrogenase, including a common S = 4 ground state, raises the issue of the existence and magnetism of other [M4S4L4](z) clusters, none of which are known with transition metals other than iron. The system CoCl2/(Pr3P)-P-i/(Me3Si)(2)S/THF assembles [Co4S4(PPr3i)41 (3), which is converted to [Co4S4((Pr2NHCMe2)-N-i)(4)] (5) upon reaction with carbene. The clusters support the redox series [3](1-/0/1+) and [5](0/1+/2+); monocatiorlis (4, 6) have been isolated by chemical oxidation. Redox potentials and substitution reactions indicate that the carbene is the more effective electron donor to tetrahedral Fell and Coll sites. Clusters 3-6 have the same overall cubane-type geometry as 9. Neutral clusters 3 and 5 have an S = 3 ground state. As with the S = 4 state of 9 with local spins S-Fe = 2, the septet spin state can be described in terms of the coupling of three parallel and one antiparallel spins S-Co= 3/2. The octanuclear clusters [Co8S8(PPr3i)(6)](0.1+) were isolated as minor by products of the formation and chemical oxidation of 3. The clusters exhibit a rhomb-bridged noncubane (RBNC) structure, whereas clusters with the Fe8S8 core possess edge-bridged double-cubane (EBDC) stereochemistry. There are two structural solutions for the M8S8 core in the form of topological isomers whose stability may depend on valence electron count. A conceptual model for the RBNC - EBDC interconversion is presented. ((Pr2NHCMe2)-N-i = C11H20N2 = 1,3-diisopropyl-4,5-dimethylimidazol-2-ylidene).