Phenols bearing -CH3 and -CHO substituents were oxidized in supercritical water at 460 degrees C and 250 atm. Experiments with each compound explored the effects of the reactor residence time and the concentrations of the phenolic compound and oxygen on the reaction rate. These experimental data were fit to global, power-law rate expressions. The resulting rate laws showed that the reactivity of the different isomers at 460 degrees C was in the order of ortho > para > meta for both compounds. Moreover, the CHO-substituted phenol was more reactive than the analogous CH3-substituted phenol, and all of these substituted phenols were more reactive than phenol itself under supercritical water oxidation conditions. Identifying and quantifying the products of incomplete oxidation allowed us to assemble a general reaction network for the oxidation of cresols in supercritical water. This network comprises three parallel primary paths. One path leads to phenol, a second path leads to a hydroxybenzaldehyde, and the third path leads to ring-opening products. The hydroxybenzaldehyde reacts through two parallel paths, which lead to phenol and to ring-opening products. Phenol also reacts via two parallel paths, but these lead to phenol dimers and ring-opening products. The dimers are eventually converted to ring-opening products, and the ring-opening products are ultimately converted to CO2. The relative rates of the different paths in the reaction network are strong functions of the location of the substituent on the phenolic ring.