Fibrin has been proposed as cell scaffold for numerous tissue engineering applications. While most of the studies have focused on fibrinogen and thrombin, other components of fibrin can also affect its properties. The present study aimed to evaluate the effects of buffer solution composition on fibrin biophysical properties. Fibrin scaffolds were synthesized with different calcium, chloride, and factor XIII (FXIII) final concentrations. Light transmission was determined as a relative, semi-quantitative estimator of fiber structure differences, and two compositions, resulting in translucent and opaque gels, were tested for mechanical and biological properties. Gels were seeded with mouse mesenchymal cells, C3H10T1/2, or bovine bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stromal cells and cultured up to 10 or 24 days, before cell number, morphology and distribution were evaluated. Calcium increased gel opacity (i.e., fiber thickness), while chloride and FXIII decreased it. Opaque gels displayed a fluid-like viscous behavior while translucent gels showed improved elastic properties. Both compositions supported survival of both cell types with opaque gels leading to better proliferation, but significant scaffold shrinkage after 17 days of culture. These results demonstrated that calcium, chloride, and FXIII modulate the biophysical properties of fibrin, and can be used to adjust mechanical and biological properties for tissue engineering applications.