Replacement of the native (as-synthesized) ligands of colloidal CdSe QDs with varying concentrations of a series of para-substituted anilines (R-An), where R ranges from strongly electron-withdrawing to strongly electron-donating, decreases the PL of the QDs. The molar ratio of R-An to OD ([R-An]:[QD]) at which the PL decreases by 50% shifts by 4 orders of magnitude over the series R-An. The model employed to describe the data combines a Freundlich binding isotherm (which reflects the dependence of the binding affinity of the amine headgroups of R-An on the substituent R) with a function that describes the response of the PL to R-An ligands once they are bound at their equilibrium surface coverage. The latter function includes as a parameter the rate constant, k(nr), for nonradiative decay of the exciton at a site to which an R-An ligand is coordinated. The value of this parameter reveals that the predominant mechanism of QD-ligand interaction is passivation of Cd2+ surface sites through sigma-donation for R-An ligands with R = H, Br, OCF3, and reductive quenching through photoinduced hole transfer for R = MeO, (Me)(2)N.