Atomic force microscopy, AFM, and nanoindentation of polyelectrolyte multilayers, PEMUs, made from poly(diallyldimethylammonium), PDADMA, and poly(styrene sulfonate), PSS, provided new insight into their surface morphology and growth mechanism. A strong odd/even alternation of surface modulus revealed greater extrinsic (counterion-balanced) charge compensation for fully hydrated multilayers ending in the polycation, PDADMA. These swings in modulus indicate a much more asymmetric layer-by-layer growth mechanism than previously proposed. Viscoelastic properties of the PEMU, which may contribute to cell response, were highlighted by variable indentation rates and minimized by extrapolating to zero indentation rate, at which point the surface and bulk equilibrium moduli were comparable. Variations in surface composition were probed at high resolution using force mapping, and the surface was found to be uniform, with no evidence of phase separation. AFM comparison of wet and dry films terminated with PSS and PDADMA revealed much greater swelling of the PDADMA-terminated PEMU by water, with collapse of surface roughness features in dry conditions. Dynamic and static contact angle measurements suggested less rearrangement for the glassy PSS surface.